Baseball.FYI ← Back

Houston Astros Lineup Could Be One of Best in Baseball

The Houston Astros missed the playoffs for the first time since 2016 last year, and the offseason questions were loud. Jose Altuve turns 36 in May. Carlos Correa’s lower body has been a medical file cabinet. Yordan Alvarez played fewer than 50 games. Fair concerns, all of them.

Thirteen games in, the Astros have the best offense in Major League Baseball, sitting at a 142 wRC+ with 79 runs scored. They’re 6-7. The production hasn’t turned into wins yet, but the firepower is real and it isn’t quiet.

Sustaining that 142 wRC+ all season? Not happening. That would beat the 2023 Braves for the best post-integration offense by 16 points. But staying a top offense wire-to-wire is a different question, and the answer might actually be yes.

Start with Alvarez.

Last year he posted a 118 wRC+ across 48 games with just six home runs. The underlying numbers were fine, an xwOBA of .393 across 199 plate appearances, but he couldn’t stay on the field and the Astros finished 15th in offense. This year he’s played all 13 games, already has four homers, a 227 wRC+, and 0.9 fWAR. That’s a completely different version of this lineup.

The thing is, Alvarez doesn’t just hurt you with the bat. His presence changes the entire at-bat sequence for every hitter around him. Pitchers can’t afford extra baserunners when he’s due up, so they attack the zone more often, and everyone in Houston benefits. He’s 28 years old and sits 26 home runs shy of 200 for his career. If he stays on the field, he gets there easy. That’s the whole season in one sentence, really. Healthy Alvarez means a dangerous Astros offense.

Then there’s Cam Smith, the headliner coming back from the Kyle Tucker trade. Through the first 13 games Smith has looked like exactly what Houston needed him to be. The wRC+ metric rewards hitters who contribute across all offensive categories, and Smith has checked multiple boxes early. This needs to be a full breakout campaign for him, not just a hot April.

The Astros have built this run for a decade by mixing elite veterans with smart acquisitions, and the FanGraphs depth chart shows a lineup that still has real teeth top to bottom. Altuve remains one of the more difficult at-bats in the American League despite the age. The supporting cast around Alvarez and Smith gives opposing pitchers no obvious place to hide.

Just Baseball noted that only three teams in the American League currently have a winning record, each one a division leader, so Houston’s 6-7 mark doesn’t look catastrophic in context. The AL West is bunched up and every series matters the same in April as it does in August.

A 142 wRC+ is a mirage. Six weeks from now it’ll look different. But the core argument for this offense being legitimately elite isn’t based on a 13-game sample. It’s based on what this lineup looks like when Alvarez plays 140 games, when Smith proves the Tucker trade wasn’t a mistake, and when the Astros’ front office gets what it paid for from its veterans.

Not a lock. But not a fluke either.

Get Baseball.FYI daily